In a now-viral episode of Jubilee’s “Surrounded” debate show, journalist Mehdi Hasan confronted PineSap in a panel of 20 conservatives on various U.S. policy issues. He was a young Christian nationalist who introduced himself as Connor—known online as PineSap—and quickly became the most controversial figure in the debate.
During the episode, Connor publicly identified as a fascist, defended General Franco, expressed his admiration for him, and dismissed concerns about being labeled a Nazi. When pressed by Hasan on his views, Connor doubled down, saying, “I’m a fascist… I don’t care if you call me a Nazi.” The moment exploded on social media, prompting widespread backlash and renewed scrutiny of online political discourse.
The Aftermath: From Exposure to Fundraising
Following the release of the episode — which has now garnered millions of views — PineSap claims he was fired from his job due to the backlash. In response, he launched a crowdfunding campaign on GiveSendGo, a Christian fundraising platform often used by far-right and extremist figures. His goal was to raise $15,000. As of this writing, he has received over $20,000, with several donations featuring coded extremist references such as the number 88 — a white supremacist symbol for “Heil Hitler.”
In a follow-up podcast appearance, PineSap defended his remarks, claiming he simply expressed “traditional right-wing views” and argued that the mainstream media and employers are suppressing ideological dissent under the guise of tolerance. His campaign has drawn both support and criticism, highlighting the polarized nature of contemporary political discourse, where individuals can find niche audiences willing to fund their extremist beliefs.
A Larger Pattern: When Platforms Amplify Extremism
Jubilee’s “Surrounded” format — in which one person defends their views against a crowd — has come under fire for sensationalizing conflict while giving voice to dangerous ideologies. While the format is intended to highlight diverse perspectives, critics argue that inviting self-identified fascists into debates undermines meaningful discourse and risks mainstreaming extremist ideas. This trend raises questions about the ethical responsibilities of platforms that prioritize sensational content over nuanced discussion.
PineSap’s rise is not an isolated case. It reflects a broader digital trend of individuals with extreme views gaining viral fame and financial backing by leveraging polarized media ecosystems. The line between political commentary and provocation continues to blur — often to the benefit of those willing to push the limits. This phenomenon is not only a reflection of personal beliefs but also an indication of how the current media landscape rewards provocative and controversial rhetoric.
Final Thoughts: Accountability or “Cancel Culture”?
PineSap and his supporters frame the reaction as an example of “cancel culture.” But to critics, it’s a clear case of accountability. Declaring allegiance to fascism, praising autocracy, and invoking Nazi-adjacent language crosses the line from political discourse into ideological extremism. The debate raises important questions about what constitutes acceptable speech and the consequences of espousing hateful ideologies in public forums.
What’s most revealing isn’t just what was said — but the financial reward that followed. In the current media environment, controversy doesn’t cancel — it converts. The attention economy rewards even the most dangerous ideas with clicks, visibility, and, in this case, cold hard cash. This dynamic underscores a troubling reality: instead of leading to social ostracism, extreme rhetoric can lead to financial gain, pushing the boundaries of how society engages with and responds to extremist ideologies. The implications of this trend extend beyond individual cases and challenge the fabric of democratic discourse, raising critical concerns about the future of political engagement in an increasingly polarized world.
Explore more in our Politics category for in-depth analysis and the latest updates on this ongoing i